Checking out the competition
So, my first task of the afternoon was to check out the apparently brilliant, witty, biting, satirical, topical, original cabaret show of last year's Best Fringe Duo, Topping and Butch. Camp as a row of pink tents, they have a huge gay'n'granny following and do two shows - one at 11 (which was obviously out) and a 4pm show called Afternoon Tease. Forgive me, Butch and Topping, you are lovely people with beautiful teeth and decent voices, but Afternoon Snooze would have been more appropriate - I only hope your evening show consists of more than reworked lyrics to Disney songs and tired knob-gags.
Innuendo and nudge-winkery are both fine cabaret traditions we are proud to uphold, but despite being blessed with a massively indulgent audience (and lubricating them with free sherry always helps), Topping and Butch barely raised a titter from me. Of an eight-song set one or two were original and the rest were old tunes with new - and not desperately hilarious - words. I went in really wanting to like them and left feeling rather cheated. Surely it can't be that hard to write something both new and funny? We give it a shot and we've only been going for eighteen months. The glorious gods of cabaret Kit and the Widow (of which more later) have been doing it for twenty years and they still come up with fresh and amusing stuff every time I see them.
(Kit and the Widow shown not actual age - but they do look lovely)
So, onto the next act of the evening, the Soubrettes. These two are a female cabaret duo from Australia who do (thank god) nothing but original songs. Again, lovely voices (and superb costumes, especially the wigs) but when we went the audience of twenty-odd felt lost in the dark and dank environment of the Gilded Balloon Caves. We were a much tougher crowd, too - while Topping and Butch's banter was (to be fair) polished and entertaining, the two girls had much fresher songs but seemed a bit lost between numbers. But again, while a lot of the songs were clever, or funny, or had a good idea behind them, very few managed to be all three at once and only the last (a song about oral sex) is still running through my head.
What was a bit more disturbing was that, looking at their CD (at £8, three quid more than ours - hurry, hurry, buy while stocks last!) everything on it was copyright 2001. This means that have been performing the same set for three years or more and haven't felt the need to add to or change any of the songs, which is a tad complacent given the hit-and-miss nature of the material.
I really wanted to enjoy them more. I really did. On the positive side, it makes me more confident in our own songs and show, and we've not being going long, so we're only going to get better as far as I'm concerned - but on the negative, I paid to be entertained by shows I was told were "hilarious" and, in the case of T&B "original" and was disappointed to various degrees on both fronts.
In conclusion, despite the fact that I had to walk three miles across town to see them, wait for an hour for a return, and have seen them twice before, Kit and the Widow are still the best cabaret in Edinburgh by a bloody long way, and I urge you to catch them before Apollo snatches them up in his golden chariot as being too good for this world. And if you can't get in (and they do sell out every single performance) - well, you know where Beauty and the Bitch are playing ...
